Amalia Schon Lawyer & Mediator
  • call Us Today
    (604) 318-8254
  • Home
  • About
  • Family Law Services
    • Collaborative Divorce
    • Family Law Agreements
    • Parenting, Guardianship & Custody
    • Child Support
    • Spousal Support
    • Family Property & Debt Division
    • Lawyer Assisted Negotiation
    • Mediation
    • Divorce
    • Unbundled Services
    • All Family Law Services
  • Testimonials
  • Blog
  • Contact
Book a Free Consultation

Family Law Agreements Part 1: Can you rely on them?

April 27, 2021
Case law, Family Law, Family law agreements, Family property, Spousal support
0 Comments
Vancouver & North Vancouver family law lawyer discusses the reliability of family law agreements

The goal of entering into a family law agreement is to achieve certainty, predictability, and finality, whether that be through a cohabitation/marriage (“prenuptial”) agreement with a new partner or a separation agreement with your ex.

A cohabitation/marriage (“prenuptial”) agreement will typically deal with the division of assets upon a possible separation and may also deal with spousal support. A separation agreement will often deal with all issues arising in a family’s situation, including parenting arrangements, property and debt division, child support and spousal support.

However, sometimes family law agreements may be set aside or varied by the BC Supreme Court if challenged by a spouse at a later date. Under the Family Law Act, our current provincial family law legislation, on an application by a spouse, the BC Supreme Court may set aside or vary a family law agreement if:

a. A spouse fails to disclose significant property or debts or other information relevant to the negotiation of the agreement. For example, a spouse fails to disclosure certain bank accounts or property owned in another jurisdiction, either intentionally or because they simply forgot.

b. A spouse takes improper advantage of the other spouse’s vulnerability, including their ignorance, need or distress. For example, one spouse convinces the other spouse that they do not need to speak to a lawyer before signing the agreement.

c. A spouse does not understand the nature or consequences of the agreement. For example, a spouse has language barriers that prevent them from understanding the deal that they are entering, or otherwise have a limited knowledge of the financial terms of the agreement.

d. Other circumstances that would, under the common law, cause all or part of a contract to be voidable. The other circumstances under common law are:

1. Unconscionability: the agreement is obviously and seriously unfair to one of the spouses. For example, a party takes advantage of a power disbalance to craft a deal that deprives a party of their basic legal rights.

2. Misrepresentation: A party signs the agreement on the basis that misleading information had been provided. For example, a party may state that the value of a certain asset is less than it is, or that their income is lower than it is.

3. Undue influence: A spouse takes advantage of a position of power over the other spouse. For example, a spouse who has more knowledge of the family’s finances may convince the other spouse to enter into a “bad deal” based on their limited information.

4. Duress: There was some pressure or stress on one of the spouses which resulted in them signing the agreement. For example, one spouse pressures another or makes threats in order to get them to enter into the agreement.

The BC Supreme Court may also set aside a family law agreement if the agreement is significantly unfair. For example, if a significant period of time has passed since the agreement was made and terms no longer operate fairly, the agreement may be set aside or varied. Further, if the spouses seemed to conduct their lives in disregard of the agreement, the court may set it aside or vary it.

So how does the Supreme Court determine whether to set aside or vary a family law agreement?

There have been a few important cases from the Supreme Court of Canada on when a court may set aside an agreement. In Miglin v. Miglin 2003 SCC 24, the Supreme Court of Canada prescribed a two-stage test (the “Miglin Test”) that a court must apply if a family law agreement is challenged.

Stage one – There are two parts to this first stage.

(1) The first part requires the court to consider the circumstances under which the agreement was negotiated and executed. A court may set aside family law agreement where one spouse was vulnerable or there was some unfairness or a flaw in the negotiation process (such as the circumstances discussed above in a-d and 1-4).

It should be noted that independent legal advice can assist in protecting against vulnerabilities and unequal bargaining power. However, independent legal advice is not a complete answer and does not always prevent an unfair agreement from being set aside. For example, unfairness resulting from a power imbalance (including the amount of funds available to one of the spouses to fund the negotiation process), lack of full disclosure, time pressure, or mental health issues may not be mitigated by independent legal advice. So just because both spouses have had legal advice, the family law agreement is not necessarily bulletproof!

(2) The second part asks whether the agreement substantially complied with the law at the time it was made.

If the agreement fails the first stage of the Miglin Test, then it may be set aside in whole or in part and the Family Law Act and the Divorce Act will apply. If the agreement does not fail the first stage, it will proceed to the second.

Stage two.

At the second stage, the court must assess whether the agreement still reflects the original intentions of the parties and the extent to which it is still in substantial compliance with the law. The party seeking to set aside the agreement will need to show that these new circumstances were not reasonably anticipated by the parties, and have led to a situation that cannot be condoned. Some degree of change in the circumstances of the parties is always foreseeable, as agreements are future-oriented the court will presume that spouses are aware that health, job markets, parental responsibilities, housing markets, and values of assets are all subject to change. It is only where the current circumstances represent a significant departure from the range of reasonable outcomes that the court may set aside the agreement.

So, what is the takeaway?

The BC courts believe that spouses should be free to choose to structure their affairs in a number of different ways, including “unequally”, and courts are reluctant to second-guess the agreements that spouses enter into. One should never enter into a less-than-favourable deal on the assumption that they can simply “deal with it later” by applying to the court for a better deal at a later date – BC courts will make their best efforts to uphold family law agreements, so make sure that your deal is acceptable to both you and your spouse. That said, courts will only intervene when necessary.

If you are going to enter into a family law agreement of any sort, make sure that both you and your spouse are entering into the agreement on mutually acceptable terms, intentionally and with full and accurate financial disclosure. Make sure that both parties have the opportunity to obtain adequate independent legal advice and be sure that you and your spouse put your mind to the possible circumstances that may unfold in the future, and how you intend your agreement to address those changing circumstances.

NOT LEGAL ADVICE. Information made available on this website is for information purposes only and is not legal advice. Do not rely on this information, nor take or fail to take any action, based upon this information. Do not disregard professional legal advice or delay in seeking legal advice because of something you have read on this website. Contact me here to discuss any specific legal issues.

Share
Previous Post
How to Lose your Excluded Property Part 1: Transfer Excluded Property into Joint Names
Next Post
Family Law Agreements Part 2: Can you rely on them?

Leave a Reply - Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked (required)

Book Your Free Legal Consultation







    Search
    Categories
    • Blog
    • Case law
    • Child support
    • COVID-19
    • Excluded property
    • Family Law
    • Family law agreements
    • Family property
    • Marriage-like relationship
    • News
    • Special or extraordinary expenses
    • Spousal support
    • Spouses
    • Uncategorized
    • Unequal division
    Testimonials
    • Amalia answers all my questions. She replies very quick in a timely manner. Very professional and very informative.

      Amalia Schon Lawyer & Mediator
      Cris man
      12/14/2021
    • Amalia Schön helped me alot during some of the darkest days of my life. I took a chance on Amalia, not knowing where to turn for help and never before finding myself in need of a Family lawyer, I did not have a clue whom to choose online.
      I found Amalia Schön online and the thing I remember most was she called herself more of a mediator in Family law than just a divorce lawyer, Amalia negotiated a fair settlement when all communications had ended and no resolution was possible on my own when my commonlaw relationship had ended very badly and abruptly. Amalia was always very professional and always responded to my queries and problems in a timely manner. Amalia Schön offered me good value, she is a quality family lawyer and mediated a fair settlement without anyone involved ending up in court.
      Amalia Schön Family Law, comes highly recommended as family mediator/lawyer by myself, I am very happy with her services and recommend her when and if you should ever need a Family lawyer!

      Amalia Schon Lawyer & Mediator
      Tim Holzworth
      12/03/2021

    Read more testimonials

    Archive
    • May 2021
    • April 2021
    • February 2021
    • January 2021
    • December 2020
    Quick Links
    • Homepage
    • About
    • Family Law Services
    • Testimonials
    • Contact
    North Vancouver Family Law

    Family law issues touch some of the most important aspects of our lives. Finding a lawyer that you can trust is imperative to achieving a timely and beneficial resolution.

    Copyright Amalia Schön © 2022. All Rights Reserved

    • Home
    • About
    • Family Law Services
      • Collaborative Divorce
      • Family Law Agreements
      • Parenting, Guardianship & Custody
      • Child Support
      • Spousal Support
      • Family Property & Debt Division
      • Lawyer Assisted Negotiation
      • Mediation
      • Divorce
      • Unbundled Services
      • All Family Law Services
    • Testimonials
    • Blog
    • Contact
    • Home
    • About
    • Family Law Services
      • Collaborative Divorce
      • Family Law Agreements
      • Parenting, Guardianship & Custody
      • Child Support
      • Spousal Support
      • Family Property & Debt Division
      • Lawyer Assisted Negotiation
      • Mediation
      • Divorce
      • Unbundled Services
      • All Family Law Services
    • Testimonials
    • Blog
    • Contact